Pin it
I picked up this pizza sauce trick while working at a small neighborhood joint in Chicago. This sauce will honestly change your pizza game forever. You can throw it together in just five minutes with eight basic items most folks have sitting in their kitchen. It's packed with such deep flavor that your homemade pizzas will taste like they came from a fancy Italian spot downtown.
The Wonder of Fresh-Made Pizza Sauce
There's something special about getting everyone together to build pizzas from the ground up. Making memories with my kids while cutting back on delivery costs has become our thing. This sauce has turned into my go-to weapon for our pizza evenings. The amazing smell that fills my house when I mix it up takes me straight back to that tiny Chicago pizza shop.
Your Pizza Sauce Essentials
- Tomato Sauce: A single can works great, but I'll use fresh ones from my backyard when summer rolls around.
- Tomato Paste: This gives you that amazing thick texture. Your pizza base will love it.
- Italian Seasoning/Oregano: Works wonderfully whether you've got dried or fresh on hand.
- Garlic Salt: This really kicks up the flavor. You can mix plain garlic powder with some sea salt too.
- Sugar: Just a tiny bit helps bring out what's already sweet in the tomatoes.
- Garlic Powder: In my kitchen, we don't hold back on the garlic.
- Onion Powder: Adds that little extra something you can't quite place.
- Black Pepper: I like using freshly ground, but whatever you've got works fine.
Pin it
Crafting Your Sauce
- Combine Your Basics
- Get a bowl and stir your tomato paste and sauce until they're completely mixed.
- Add Some Flavor
- Toss in your oregano, Italian seasoning, garlic powder, onion powder, garlic salt, pepper and sugar. Stir until everything's blended nicely.
- Put It On Your Pizza
- Don't be shy - put plenty on your dough. I always say the sauce makes all the difference.
My Trick for Outstanding Pizza
After tons of pizza nights, I've found that sauce really can make or wreck your whole pie. It's basically the foundation everything else builds on. I never skimp and always spread a good thick layer because going light on sauce is where many folks go wrong. You want something substantial enough to hold up those toppings without turning your crust all mushy.
How To Store Your Leftover Sauce
I keep mine in a glass jar in the fridge and it stays good for about two weeks. For bigger batches, I split it into smaller containers and stick them in the freezer. They last about three months and thaw out perfectly. Just don't forget to let it warm up a bit before you put it on your dough.
Quick Facts About This Sauce
You'll get enough for two large pizzas or four small ones from one batch. I usually make double because we go through it so fast at my place. This isn't just regular pasta sauce. I tweaked this recipe specifically to be thicker and pack more punch so your pizzas come out amazing every time.
Pin it
Easy Swaps When You're Out of Stuff
We've all been there - halfway through making something and missing an ingredient. Here's what works: Blend up some fresh tomatoes instead of using canned sauce. Mix regular garlic powder with some salt if you don't have garlic salt. Leave out the sugar or use a little honey instead. The sauce turns out great no matter what you swap in.
Why Tomato Paste Matters Most
In my kitchen, tomato paste isn't optional. It gives your sauce that perfect thickness that sticks to your dough and creates a solid base for your toppings. Without it, you'll end up with runny sauce and nobody wants to bite into a pizza with a soggy bottom.
No Cooking Needed For Better Taste
One thing I love is that you don't need to cook this sauce at all. Just mix it up and you're done. The flavors stay super bright and fresh and honestly it tastes better than ones I've spent hours cooking. Plus who wants to stand around the stove when you could be making pizza?
Pizza Sauce vs Regular Sauce
I found this out the hard way. Pizza sauce needs to be different from what you'd put on pasta. Your pizza sauce should be thick enough to stay in place and packed with flavor. I watched too many homemade pizzas turn into a soggy mess using regular pasta sauce before I figured this out. The extra tomato paste and spices in here really make it work.
Fantastic Pizza Combos
This sauce works great with all types of pizza. We love plain cheese and pepperoni at our house but it's amazing on BBQ chicken pizza too. When I'm feeling lazy I just spread it on some French bread for a quick dinner. I pair it with my go-to pizza dough and sometimes with wheat dough when I'm trying to be a bit healthier.
Pin it
Clever Ways To Keep It Fresh
Over time I've picked up some tricks for storing this sauce. Glass containers keep it freshest in the fridge for up to two weeks. When freezing, I use small containers so I can grab just what I need. The sauce spreads way better when it's not cold, so I always let it sit out a bit before making pizza.
Creating Memories On Pizza Night
Our kitchen becomes the busiest spot in the house on pizza nights. My kids love spreading sauce and choosing their toppings. There's something magical about cooking together, and this quick sauce means we spend less time prepping and more time hanging out as a family.
Homemade Beats Store-Bought
After years of buying sauce in jars, I can't believe I waited so long to make my own. The stuff from the store just doesn't come close to this fresh sauce. I know exactly what's in it and can change the flavors to suit what my family likes. No weird ingredients or preservatives anywhere.
Customizing Your Sauce
I love tweaking this sauce and you should try it too. Sometimes I add some red pepper flakes when I want it spicy. During summer I'll throw in fresh basil from outside. My sister adds roasted garlic to hers. Your kitchen, your call. Play around until you find what tastes best to you.
Pin it
Nailing That Perfect Consistency
After making this sauce countless times, I've learned some texture tricks. Give everything a good stir to get rid of any lumps. The sauce should be thick enough to coat a spoon. If it seems too thick, add tiny bits of water until it looks right, but remember thicker sauce means your pizza won't get soggy.
Fixing Common Sauce Problems
Sometimes things don't go perfectly in the kitchen. If your sauce is too runny, add a spoonful of tomato paste. Too sour? A bit of sugar fixes that right up. I always start with less seasoning because you can add more but you can't take it out once it's in there. Trust how it tastes and adjust as you go.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long can I keep this sauce fresh?
- In a tightly sealed container, this sauce lasts two weeks in the fridge. You can also freeze it for up to two months so it'll stay good longer.
- → Can I leave out the sugar?
- Definitely skip it or swap in honey if you'd like. Sugar boosts tomato flavor and smooths acidity but still tastes great without it.
- → Why do we need tomato paste in this?
- The thick paste gives the sauce that perfect texture for sticking to pizza dough. It also prevents sogginess and adds big tomato flavor.
- → Can I choose fresh herbs instead?
- Go ahead and use fresh ones. Since they're more intense, start with smaller amounts and tweak until it tastes perfect for you.
- → What’s the best way to store leftovers?
- Pop it in the fridge using a tight container. Let it warm up to room temperature before using, as cold sauce thickens considerably.