Pin it
This velvety oven-finished potato mash takes everyday spuds to new heights, creating a restaurant-worthy side that'll have everyone begging for the recipe. The baking step adds an amazing depth that makes these potatoes way better than regular mash. They're spot-on for holiday tables, dinner parties, or whenever you want to wow your guests.
I stumbled on this baking trick during a family Thanksgiving prep several years back, and it totally changed our potato game forever. Now my kids turn up their noses at regular mashed potatoes and always ask for these "special potatoes" whenever we're celebrating anything.
What You'll Need
- 5 pounds russet potatoes: Go for these starchy ones to get the fluffiest results and best butter absorption
- 8 tablespoons melted salted butter: Adds wonderful richness throughout
- 2 tablespoons cold salted butter: Creates yummy little butter spots during baking
- 8 ounces softened cream cheese: The magic ingredient for unbelievable smoothness
- 1 cup half and half: Gives that decadent feel without making things watery
- 1/2 teaspoon salt: Brings out the potato's natural goodness
- Freshly ground black pepper: Adds a gentle hint of spice
- Optional fresh chives: Gives a pop of color and light oniony kick
How To Make It
- Get potatoes ready:
- Take the skin off your russets and chop them into same-sized chunks about an inch big. Making them all similar helps them cook evenly. Give them a good rinse in cold water to wash away extra starch that can make them gummy. Drop them in a big pot with cold water and throw in a few big pinches of salt. Starting cold helps cook potatoes through properly.
- Cook them right:
- Put it on high heat until boiling, then let them bubble away for about 10-15 minutes until tender. You should be able to stick a fork in easily, but they shouldn't fall apart. If they get too soft, they'll soak up water and turn soupy.
- Dry them out:
- After draining really well, put potatoes back in the hot pot. Keep them over low heat for exactly 3 minutes, stirring now and then. This key step gets rid of extra moisture, making them fluffier and ready to soak up all the good stuff. Look for steam coming off and a slightly dried look on the outside.
- Mix the foundation:
- Move your steamed potatoes to a big bowl or stand mixer. Beat them briefly on low just to break them up, but don't go overboard. Too much mixing releases starch and makes them gluey. Add the warm melted butter, salt and pepper while everything's still hot so the flavors blend better.
- Make them smooth:
- Mix in the softened cream cheese chunks while running the mixer on low. Slowly pour in warm half and half bit by bit until you like how thick they are. You might not need it all. Give it a taste and add more salt if needed, keeping in mind they already soaked some up during boiling.
- Bake until amazing:
- Spread everything into a greased 9x13 baking dish in an even layer. Dot little cold butter pieces all over the top to create tasty butter spots throughout. Bake at 350°F for 45 minutes until the top gets a beautiful golden color and the edges start bubbling.
Pin it
This dish always reminds me of my grandma who used to say mashed potatoes should be "fancy enough to eat on their own." She showed me how a bit more care with simple ingredients can turn everyday food into something unforgettable. Every time these potatoes are baking, the smell takes me straight back to her kitchen.
Prepare It Ahead
These potatoes are a lifesaver for big meals and holidays. Just do everything except the baking step, wrap the dish tightly with plastic, and keep it in the fridge for up to two days. When you're ready to eat, take it out about 30 minutes before to warm up a bit, then bake as normal but add another 10-15 minutes to the cooking time. They'll come out just as amazing as if you'd made them from scratch, with none of the last-minute rushing around.
Pin it
Goes Great With
These creamy spuds go with pretty much any main dish from a simple roast chicken to a fancy holiday turkey or beef roast. Their rich texture works really well with anything saucy or gravy-topped since the slight crust from baking helps them hold up without turning to mush. For regular weeknight dinners, try them with meatloaf or pork chops for a meal that feels special without tons of extra work.
Fixing Texture Problems
Getting that perfect mashed potato texture means finding the right balance of moisture and starch. If yours seem too wet after mixing, toss in a few spoons of instant potato flakes to soak up the extra liquid without changing the taste. If they're too dry, warm up a splash more half and half before mixing it in. Keep in mind potatoes keep soaking up liquid while they bake, so the mix should be a bit looser than you want the final dish. Always taste before it goes in the oven and add more salt if needed - potatoes usually need more seasoning than you'd think.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What potatoes work best for this dish?
Russets are your go-to—they're starchy and make the mashed potatoes light and fluffy.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
Sure! Make the mashed potatoes, cover tightly with plastic wrap, and chill. Add more baking time when reheating.
- → How do I make the potatoes silky smooth?
Cook them until they slide off a fork, steam to get rid of moisture, then blend in butter, cream cheese, and half and half.
- → Can I swap out half and half?
You can go with milk, but keep in mind it won't be as rich—use a bit less since milk is thinner.
- → Any tips for more flavor?
Mix in shredded gouda or sharp cheddar with the cream cheese for an even cheesier dish.
- → Why should I steam the potatoes after boiling?
It dries them out so there's no extra water, which makes your mashed potatoes creamy and fluffy.