Pin it
When you bring this Caramelized Banana Cheesecake out, nobody looks away. It’s smooth and creamy, topped with gooey bananas that turn buttery and sweet, giving each bite a hint of caramel. It’s my go-to for birthdays or family get-togethers since it always brings the wow and nobody can resist a second helping—whether they’re banana fans or cheesecake diehards.
The first time I made one, it disappeared way too fast. Now, my sister won’t let me get away without making it when she visits. Watching everyone scramble for that last piece makes my day.
Delightful Ingredients
- Cream cheese: The creamy main event Let blocks soften before using for best results
- Eggs: Give the cake shape and set it up right Let them warm to room temp for smooth blending
- Sour cream: Adds both tang and makes each bite extra soft Go with the full-fat kind for best texture
- Vanilla extract: Blends the caramel and banana tastes Real vanilla makes a big difference
- Ripe bananas: Sweet and just right for caramelizing Choose ones speckled with brown spots
- Brown sugar: Melts up rich caramel goodness Use fresh, soft brown sugar for quick mixing
- Butter: Makes everything glossy and adds flavor Don’t skip real butter here
- Cornstarch: If you want the glaze thick, add a little here It keeps the sauce from dripping too much
- Graham cracker crumbs: That crunchy, familiar base Crush them fresh for better taste
- Granulated sugar: Adds sweetness and helps keep things stuck together Fine sugar mixes in best
- Unsalted butter: Everything holds together and adds richness Stick with actual butter for best results
Easy-to-Follow Steps
- Assemble and Serve:
- Once chilled, put your caramel bananas right on top while arranging them however you like Drizzle the warm glaze across the whole pie Cut slices with a knife you’ve dipped in hot water and dried off Serve with even more glaze on each piece if you want to go all out
- Make the Glaze:
- Melt butter and brown sugar in a pan slowly, stirring till everything looks shiny Want it thicker? Blend a bit of cornstarch with water and pour it in Let it bubble for a minute—turns it extra creamy Pull it off the heat when it thickens up
- Caramelize the Bananas:
- Start with melted butter in a pan over medium Add brown sugar and wait until you see bubbles Then add thick banana slices Let them sit until one side goes dark and caramel, then flip Finish so they’re coated and tender but not falling apart Cool a bit so it won’t melt your cheesecake
- Bake and Chill:
- Pour your cheesecake mix onto the cooled crust, smoothing the top Lightly bake at 325°F until the edges look sturdy and the center wiggles just a bit Prop the oven door open and let it rest inside for an hour This keeps cracks away Chill, uncovered, in your fridge at least four hours (or overnight) for the creamiest bite
- Prepare the Cheesecake Filling:
- For that dreamy texture, whip cream cheese by itself first Add sugar and keep mixing till it’s shiny and puffy Mix in eggs one by one, going slow so the batter stays smooth Wipe the bowl sides down to get everything in Last, mix in the vanilla and sour cream a little Don’t go crazy with mixing or the cake will set wrong
- Make the Crust:
- You’ll start by mixing graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and melted butter till it looks like damp sand Press it down into your springform pan with a glass bottom to pack it nicely Smooth up the sides with your fingers Bake at 350°F until just toasty, then cool down before filling
Pin it
When you cook the bananas, they fill the kitchen with a sweet, buttery smell I can’t get enough of—it’s a mini memory of sneaking bites with my grandma on rainy days and all of us gathering around the table
Storing Advice
To keep it fresh and moist, wrap tight in plastic or pop it into a sealing container and chuck it in the fridge—it’ll stay yummy up to four days Freeze single slices the same way, then thaw in the fridge overnight before eating The bananas taste best made fresh but you can get the glaze ready ahead of time and stash separately
Swap Options
No graham crackers around? Use vanilla wafers or digestive cookies Dairy-free? Go for plant-based cream cheese and sour cream, and use coconut oil for the crust Coconut sugar swaps in for brown, and gluten-free cookies work, too
Pin it
Serve It Up
This sweet treat stands up on its own, but you can always add a dollop of whipped cream or some vanilla ice cream For fun, sprinkle on chopped toasted pecans or just a bit of flaky sea salt Enjoy it cold on hot days, or warm up a slice a little when you want something cozier
Food Traditions
Banana desserts have fans everywhere—think Caribbean bananas flambéed or gooey Southern banana pudding This is a fresh take on Banoffee pie, with caramel and tropical fruit teaming up for that party feel every time
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which bananas caramelize well?
Go with bananas that are yellow but still pretty solid. They'll caramel up great and won't fall apart.
- → Can I make the crust with something else?
Definitely, swap in vanilla cookies or biscuits if you’re out of graham crackers.
- → How do I keep my cheesecake from splitting?
Let your cheesecake slowly cool down in the oven, propping the door a bit, so it sets gently without cracks.
- → Is it okay to prep this a day early?
You bet—make everything the night before, then add bananas and glaze when you’re ready to eat.
- → Do I have to pour on the glaze?
You don’t have to but that gooey sugar glaze makes it pop and look awesome.