Brownie Birthday Cake Layers

Fudgy brownie layers paired with smooth chocolate icing make this Brownie Birthday Cake a crowd-pleaser for any party. It's a chocolate-packed dessert for anyone who thinks brownies always deserve the spotlight, finished off with lots of colorful sprinkles for a fun touch.

I first made this for my family when someone begged for brownies instead of a regular cake. Now it pops up at every big get together or chocolate craving.

Decadent Ingredients

• Rainbow sprinkles: bring the celebration with a little crunch and color grab ones that really stand out
• Vanilla extract: boosts the chocolate vibe and adds a warm, sweet finish real vanilla is the way to go
• Milk: loosens up the icing for easy spreading whole milk is awesome but any will do
• Powdered sugar: blends in a mellow sweetness sift it so your frosting turns out silky
• Cocoa powder: gives intense chocolate punch to both icing and brownie layers use Dutch or natural, but pick the good cocoa
• For icing Unsalted butter: let it sit out so it whips up fluffy and creamy
• Salt: keeps the sweetness in check and lifts the chocolate
• All purpose flour: gives these brownies structure, not cakiness, use the spoon-and-level tip for best results
• Cocoa powder: creates deep chocolate flavor, make sure it’s high quality
• Vanilla extract: rounds out all of the chocolate notes
• Large eggs: let them come to room temp so everything mixes smooth and bakes up rich shoot for vibrant yolks
• Light brown sugar: makes brownies moist and nicely caramel-y stick to the soft, fresh kind
• Unsalted butter: the backbone of the brownies, giving them lots of moisture and rich flavor

Simple How-To Steps

Put it all together:

Set your first round on your serving dish, pile on half the icing and sprinkles, gently top with the second round, finish with more icing and the rest of your sprinkles

Frosting time:

Beat soft butter until smooth, blend in cocoa, powdered sugar, a splash of milk and vanilla, then whip it all until fluffy. Add extra milk if it needs to spread easier.

Let everything cool down:

Let them hang out in the pans for ten minutes, run a knife around the sides, then ease them onto a rack. Wait till they're totally cool before reaching for the frosting.

Bake up the brownie:

Pour batter in two lined pans, even the tops, bake at 350 F for about 30-35 minutes. Poke the middle with a toothpick—just a few sticky crumbs is perfect.

Mix dry and wet:

Sprinkle in flour, cocoa, and salt, and gently fold into the wet stuff with a spatula until you don’t see loose flour, batter will be nice and thick.

Stir up the brownie mix:

Melt butter, let it cool down for a second, stir in sugar, then eggs one at a time, finishing with vanilla. Whisk till shiny and combined nicely.

Prep your pans:

Spray the pans, line bottoms with parchment, so nothing sticks when you flip them out later

Pin it

The best part is dumping in heaps of my favorite sprinkles. Every birthday, my siblings and I used to battle it out for the piece that had the crunchiest edge.

Storing Advice

Cover your brownie cake and it'll be tasty at room temp for around three days. Want to keep it longer? Chill it (wrapped up well) and it'll last about five. Freezer-friendly, too—just thaw out those brownie layers before stacking it all together for the party.

Switch-Ups for Ingredients

Try dark brown sugar if you want more molasses-y flavor, just know it might feel a little heavier. Skip sprinkles? Use chocolate chips or chopped legit nuts instead. Need it dairy-free? Grab plant-based margarine and your favorite non-dairy milk for brownies and frosting both.

Pin it

How to Serve

This super rich cake is awesome by itself, but a scoop of ice cream or fresh berries makes it extra special. Feeling fancy? Sprinkle a little sea salt on top for a great salty-sweet bite.

Surprising Brownie Cake Origins

Brownie cakes got their start as a fun switch from classic birthday cakes since so many folks wanted a more rich, chewy texture. Laying brownies with icing is a pretty fresh idea, but it’s totally caught on and is now super popular in kitchens everywhere.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do I keep brownies soft?

Stick with room temp eggs and measure your flour right so brownies won’t get dry. Don’t go too long in the oven or they’ll lose that fudgy bite.

→ Which cocoa should I grab?

Pick up unsweetened cocoa for big chocolate taste. Dutch-process is a good choice if you want darker looks and deeper flavor.

→ How do I stack layers cleanly?

Let them cool in the pan till they’re fully set, then turn out gently. Pop them in the fridge for a bit if you want firmer layers before building.

→ Is making this ahead okay?

Yup, mix up brownies and frosting ahead so you're not rushed. Put it all together right before you serve for the best combo of soft and smooth.

→ What's the best way to save leftovers?

Cover tightly and leave out for a couple days, or chill in the fridge if you want it to last. Bring it back to room temp before grabbing another slice.

→ Are sprinkles a must?

You don’t have to use sprinkles, but they definitely brighten things up. Add any colors you want or skip them for that classic all-chocolate vibe.