Creamy Butterscotch Cheesecake

This velvety butterscotch cheesecake turns regular get-togethers into special moments with its smooth filling and crispy crumble on top. The scratch-made butterscotch brings a cozy feeling that makes this treat stand out from regular cheesecakes, giving you different textures and tastes in every bite.

I came up with this cheesecake for my sister's birthday when she asked for something "not ordinary but not too out there." Now our family wants it at pretty much every holiday we celebrate together.

Ingredients

For the Crust

• Graham cracker crumbs: They form that familiar base with hints of honey flavor
• Unsalted butter: Holds everything together and adds richness; try European style for better taste
• Granulated sugar: Cuts the saltiness and helps the crust turn golden when it bakes
• Salt: Brings out all other flavors; kosher salt works best here

For the Cheesecake Filling

• Cream cheese: Makes our smooth base; always pick full fat and let it warm up for best mixing
• Light brown sugar: Gives richer flavor than plain white sugar with tiny hints of molasses
• Large eggs: Add firmness and richness; don't use them cold from the fridge
• Vanilla extract: Brings lovely background flavor; worth getting the good stuff
• Heavy cream: Makes everything super smooth; regular pasteurized works better than ultra
• Butterscotch chips: Turn into gooey goodness throughout the cheesecake

For the Buttery Crumble Topping

• All purpose flour: Gives the crumble its shape
• Light brown sugar: Gets all golden and tasty while baking
• Cold unsalted butter: Makes those yummy crumbly bits
• Salt: Balances the sweet stuff; you can't skip this

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Crust

Combine:

Mix graham crumbs with melted butter, sugar, and salt until everything's wet for good sticking. Push firmly into your pan using a measuring cup's bottom to make it flat and tight. This keeps your crust from falling apart when you serve it. Bake just until you can smell it and it's barely golden, which makes a barrier that keeps water out of our filling.

Create the Cheesecake Filling

Beat:

Mix cream cheese until it's totally smooth before adding anything else, making sure it looks like thick frosting with zero lumps. Stir in brown sugar really well until the mix gets lighter in color, showing you've put air in it. Put eggs in one at a time, letting each one mix in fully before adding another, which stops overmixing that can make cracks. Gently fold in heavy cream to keep those air bubbles that make it light. Add melted butterscotch chips while they're still warm but not hot so they spread evenly through the mix.

Craft the Buttery Crumble

Work:

Fast with cold stuff to get those tasty butter chunks that make this cheesecake extra good. Stir dry things first so salt and sugar spread out evenly. Cut butter into little squares, then rub into flour mix with your fingers until you get different sized bits from tiny to bigger chunks. Having different sizes makes each bite more fun. Stick it in the fridge if it gets too warm from your hands.

Bake with Care

Place:

Your pan on a cookie sheet to catch any butter that might leak from the crust. Bake until the middle wobbles just a little bit, like jello that's almost set, while the sides look firmer. The crumble should turn golden brown without burning. Don't open the oven during the first 40 minutes of cooking, as this can make the temperature drop fast and cause cracks. Let it cool slowly in the turned-off oven, which stops the quick temperature change that breaks cheesecakes.

Perfect the Chill

Refrigerate:

Without covering for the first hour, then put foil loosely on top for the rest of the time. This keeps water drops from falling onto your pretty crumble. Try to let it chill overnight whenever you can, as the flavors get much better during this time.

Pin it

The butterscotch chips really make this dish shine. After trying lots of different versions I found that melting them before mixing them in spreads the flavor evenly instead of having super sweet spots. My mother-in-law, who thought she hated butterscotch, completely changed her mind after trying this cheesecake and now loves it.

Getting That Smooth Texture

The key to that dreamy creamy texture is taking your time. Let all your dairy stuff sit out until it reaches room temp, which usually takes about two hours on the counter. This temp change helps everything mix properly and stops those tiny bumps that show up in many homemade cheesecakes. Also, beating just the cream cheese first before adding other stuff builds that silky base that makes this dessert so good.

Stopping Those Annoying Cracks

While the crumbly top hides any mistakes, you can get a perfectly smooth cheesecake by using a water bath. Just wrap your pan in a few layers of heavy-duty foil, going all the way up the sides, then put it in a bigger pan with hot water that comes halfway up the cheesecake pan. This gentle moist heat stops the quick temp changes that cause cracking. Letting it cool slowly in the turned-off oven also helps keep it from breaking.

Serving Suggestions

This butterscotch cheesecake tastes amazing with some warm salted caramel sauce drizzled on top for extra yumminess. For a nice contrast, add a bit of barely sweetened whipped cream with a touch of brown sugar and vanilla. In fall, try sprinkling some cinnamon in the whipped cream for that cozy feeling. For a really fancy look, warm up a few spoonfuls of butterscotch chips with a spoonful of heavy cream to make a sauce, then drizzle it over each slice right before serving.

Make It Your Own

You can easily change this recipe to suit your taste. Try adding a pinch of cinnamon to the crust for extra warmth. Mix some chopped toasted pecans into the crumble for a nutty crunch. If you love chocolate, swirl in some melted dark chocolate just before baking. During summer, a spoonful of bourbon in the filling adds grown-up flavor that goes well with the butterscotch. The basic recipe is great as is but also works as a starting point for your own ideas.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap out the crust for something else?

Absolutely! Consider replacing the graham cracker crust with crushed Oreos, biscuits, or shortbread for variety in flavor.

→ What’s the safest way to melt butterscotch chips?

Heat the butterscotch chips in a microwave-safe dish, stirring every 15 seconds to prevent burning, until fully melted and smooth.

→ How do I achieve a perfectly smooth filling?

Let your cream cheese warm to room temperature, then beat it together with brown sugar until no lumps remain before adding other ingredients.

→ Should I prepare this dessert in advance?

The best results come from making it a day before, allowing the cheesecake to chill overnight for the perfect set texture and flavor.

→ How do I keep the crumble topping crunchy?

Start with cold butter and mix it until crumbly. Sprinkle it only just before baking for the best crispy finish.