Pin it
This classic Amish custard brings together smooth comfort and creamy goodness that'll make you want a second helping. The delicate vanilla and melt-in-your-mouth feel are just so satisfying. Whip it up to treat yourself on a quiet evening or share the goodness at a family get-together.
This custard made its first mark at a small-town supper and now I bake it whenever I want something soothing. Every time a bit of nutmeg and vanilla wafts through the house I’m back in those good old memories.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Nutmeg—garnish: this adds a cozy spicy kick Grating it fresh brings out even more flavor
- Salt: just a small dash makes everything taste brighter Sea salt is a nice choice if you have it
- Vanilla extract: brings that irresistible warm scent Go for the real stuff for great results
- Eggs: these little guys help your custard puff up and turn silky Fresh eggs really do make a difference
- Hot water: mixes things together super well Use clean water for the freshest taste
- Sweetened condensed milk: this is what gives custard its sweet creamy base If you can find it without extra additives, all the better
Easy Steps
- Let It Cool and Add Nutmeg:
- Let the finished custard cool on the counter for about an hour Shake plenty of nutmeg over the top Enjoy it warm for a pudding-like texture or stash in the fridge to get it firmer and chilly
- Check if It’s Done:
- Bake about an hour for tiny ramekins or up to 100 minutes in a big dish Check by sliding a knife in the center—if it comes out clean it’s ready
- Set Up the Water Bath:
- Put your filled ramekins or dish in a big pan and move everything to the oven Carefully pour in half an inch of hot water so the custard won’t dry out
- Get Ready to Bake:
- Pour the custard into your ramekins or a baking dish Pop them into a bigger pan so they’ll be set for the water bath soon
- Mix in What’s Left:
- Now stir the vanilla and salt into your smooth mixture Don’t overmix—just enough till it smells amazing
- Add the Eggs:
- Slowly add a splash of hot milk stuff into the eggs while whisking to keep things from scrambling Pour all that egg into your big bowl and whisk well for no lumps
- Whisk Your Eggs Fluffy:
- Take another bowl and beat your eggs till they’re pale and kind of frothy An electric mixer makes it easy but a regular whisk works too
- Blend Water and Milk:
- Whisk hot water with sweetened condensed milk in a big metal or glass bowl Keep going till it’s one creamy mix This is your base
- Preheat the Oven:
- Turn the oven to 325 Fahrenheit or 163 Celsius You want low and gentle heat for silky custard that doesn’t crack
Pin it
Eggs make everything magic here. They turn ordinary stuff into a smooth rich treat I love. My grandma always dusted nutmeg on these at sunset—and every bite brings back sitting with her on the porch.
How to Store It
Pop leftover custard in the fridge with a lid and you’re set for up to four days. To warm it up, heat short bursts in the microwave till it’s just right.
Easy Ingredient Swaps
No sweetened condensed milk? Use full fat evaporated milk with some sugar to get the same sweetness. If you want non-dairy, try plain coconut milk—it’ll taste a little different, but still good.
How to Serve
This custard’s great right from the dish, or make it fancy with whipped cream, jammy fruit, or a handful of fresh berries. I love it in summer with some sliced peaches piled on top.
Pin it
Where It All Began
Amish baked custard pops up at church potlucks and backyard gatherings all over the countryside. It’s proof you can make something special with just a few basics. It always reminds me of the simple joy and care that goes into home cooking.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How can you make sure your custard comes out smooth?
Mix the eggs gently, then slowly stir in hot milk. This way, they warm up nicely together. If you want it extra silky, just pour it through a strainer before baking.
- → Why do you bake custard in a water bath?
The water bath keeps heat even and gentle, so your custard cooks just right—never too quick, always super creamy.
- → Is cold Amish custard any good?
Totally! It tastes great straight from the fridge. Chilling deepens the flavor and makes it extra smooth to eat.
- → What's a good pan for baking this dessert?
Go for ramekins if you want single servings. Or grab a deep baking dish for a big batch. Both give you even baking and a soft center.
- → Why put nutmeg on baked custard?
Nutmeg gives a cozy smell and a hint of spice, which balances out that creamy sweetness perfectly.