Pin it
If you're craving a little southern comfort, this creamy Creole snapper is perfect for making any night special. The fish turns out tender under a crisp top and the sauce packs that unmistakable Louisiana punch. Pile it on fluffy rice or scoop up the sauce with some toasted bread for a meal that instantly feels like a celebration.
The first time I made this, I wanted that New Orleans taste at home—no long wait for a table needed. The sauce came together crazy fast and it’s now a staple in my weeknight rotation.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Fresh parsley: a bright topper that makes every plate pretty. Flat leaf packs the most punch
- Diced tomatoes (optional): if you want extra freshness. Go for garden tomatoes or good canned ones for ease
- Chicken broth: gives the sauce a savory backbone. Use your own or pick low sodium from the store
- Heavy cream: makes things velvety rich. Simple ingredients mean better taste
- Cayenne pepper: spice things up as much as you want. You can always add more if you like it hot
- Creole seasoning: brings that Louisiana vibe. Blended at home is less salty
- Fresh garlic: gives the whole thing amazing aroma. Choose firm, tight buds
- Onion and bell pepper: build your flavor from the ground up. Shiny, heavy veggies taste best
- Unsalted butter: starts your sauce off rich and smooth. Good-quality butter really stands out
- Garlic powder: quick punch of flavor for the fish
- Paprika: brings earthy spice and color. Spanish paprika is extra tasty
- Salt and black pepper: the classic duo to lift every flavor
- Olive oil: your go-to for pan-searing and flavoring. Extra virgin is a win
- Red snapper fillets: mild, slightly sweet fish that holds together well. Look for firm, clear flesh and no funky odors
Easy-Step Guide
- Add the Final Touch:
- Shower everything with chopped parsley before digging in. Get your favorite sides and get ready to scoop up that sauce
- Reunite Fish and Sauce:
- Snuggle your snapper pieces into the sauce, then ladle some on top. Let it sit a minute or so to heat up
- Finish That Sauce:
- Pour in the heavy cream and turn the heat down low. Let it gently bubble for about five minutes until it thickens a bit and coats a spoon
- Deglaze and Simmer:
- Add chicken broth and optional tomatoes, scraping any tasty bits off the bottom. Keep everything bubbling for a few minutes to build up all the flavor goodness
- Boost the Set-Up:
- Mix in garlic, Creole seasoning, and cayenne now. Give it a good stir and cook just a minute so it smells awesome but the garlic’s not brown
- Soften Everything Up:
- Lower the heat, drop in the butter, and let it melt. Toss in chopped onion and bell pepper, stirring until everything’s soft and smells great—about five minutes
- Sear the Fish:
- Heat up olive oil in your big skillet. Place the fish carefully and cook both sides until golden and flakey, three or four minutes per side. Set it aside and keep it warm
- Get Fish Ready:
- Press fillets dry with a towel to make sure they brown well. Sprinkle over salt, pepper, garlic powder, and paprika all over for max flavor
Pin it
Look for fish that smells fresh and has shiny, clear eyes. Every time I serve this, the family lights up—it still reminds me of the first time I nailed that Creole sauce, and how much it meant for Dad to love it.
Leftover Ideas
Let the meal cool down all the way before you pack it up tight for the fridge. It'll stay tasty for about two days. To warm up, go slow and let the fish and sauce heat on low so the snapper keeps its juicy bite and your sauce stays smooth.
Swap-Out Suggestions
No snapper on hand? Flounder, grouper, or tilapia are just as good with their mild taste and sturdy texture. Try half and half if you're low on cream, though the sauce won't be quite as thick. Out of Creole seasoning? Make your own with a combo of garlic and onion powder, paprika, and cayenne.
Ways to Serve
This works great with brown or jasmine rice to soak up every drop. Creamy mashed potatoes are a dream, but don't skip a chunk of crunchy baguette. For greens, try quick-sautéed beans or roasted asparagus—they keep things light and balanced.
Pin it
Creole History
Creole cooking blends influences like Spanish, French, West African, and Native American styles. You'll always find plenty of peppers, onions, spice, and a splash of cream in the biggest crowd-pleasers. The “holy trinity” you always hear about? It’s just onions, bell pepper, and tomato, and it makes every sauce taste amazing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I know when red snapper is cooked through?
You'll see the fillets turn white and they’ll start coming apart easily with a fork. Be careful not to cook too long or the fish will dry out. Just keep an eye during those last minutes.
- → Can I adjust the heat level of the sauce?
Absolutely! Leave out the cayenne if you don’t want much heat. If you like it spicier, just toss in a bit more cayenne or some extra Creole seasoning until it’s got the kick you want.
- → What sides pair best with this dish?
It's great with fluffy rice, creamy mashed potatoes, or a slice of crunchy French bread. Anything that’ll help you scoop up the sauce will do the trick.
- → Can I substitute another fish for red snapper?
Sure! Try flaky white fish like tilapia, cod, or grouper if snapper is tough to find. Just keep an eye on the time so you don’t overcook the fish.
- → How can I thicken the Creole sauce further?
Just let the sauce bubble without a lid for a bit. Stir from time to time and it’ll thicken up smooth and silky.