Pin it
These little lemon impossible pies have the softest, silkiest citrus center and everyone gobbles them up whenever I share They always get smiles because of that punchy lemony custard in the middle
The first time I brought these for a sunny picnic they were gone before I even had a second one Every year my aunt requests them once it gets warm out
Dreamy Ingredients
- Lemon zest: all the sunny aroma comes out when you zest right before baking Try not to get any of the white part cause it's bitter
- Granulated sugar: brings that crisp finish and pure sweet taste I like cane sugar best for this
- Milk: keeps it extra creamy Use full fat milk for maximum silkiness
- Large eggs: makes everything hold together better Let them sit out first so they're not cold
- All purpose flour: makes the texture soft Just be sure it's not old so your pies taste their best
- Fresh lemon juice: packs the pies with tartness Give the lemons a roll first to get more juice out
- Salt: wakes up all the flavors and balances sweetness A tiny pinch of fine sea salt works well
- Butter, unsalted and melted: adds that craveable rich bite I pick brands with a lot of milkfat
Simple Step Guide
- Cool and Enjoy:
- Let them chill for ten minutes before taking them out If they're sticky use a thin spatula Once they're on a rack finish cooling Serve straight from the fridge or let them sit—either way's tasty
- Bake Time:
- Slide the tray into the hot oven Bake twenty five to thirty minutes Pies will look golden and springy in the center when done
- Add Batter to Pan:
- Pour the batter gently into the oiled mini pie spaces Don't fill to the top—leave space for them to puff up
- Blend It All Together:
- While stirring, pour the wet mixture into your bowl of dry stuff Scrape down the sides Look for a totally smooth, glossy batter with no hidden flour bits
- Wet Ingredients First:
- Crack the eggs, pour in milk, fresh lemon juice, and zest in another bowl Whisk well so it all comes together nicely A fork's okay if you don't have a whisk
- Dry Mix Magic:
- Dump flour, sugar, and salt in a big bowl Mix well so you don't get any lumpy bits later
- Fire Up the Oven:
- Switch your oven to 350 F Give your mini pie pan a good butter or spray job so nothing sticks and you won't struggle to get pies out
Pin it
I wait all year for the moment I get to zest lemons Smells so bright My youngest begs to help He’s got the best dance moves in the kitchen and demands zester duty every single time—cracks me up
Storage Advice
Tuck leftovers in a closed container and chill in the fridge up to four days They'll keep their creamy texture—maybe even get tastier Let them thaw at room temp if you freeze them individually but honestly they’re usually gone fast here
Swap Options
Out of fresh lemons? Bottled juice can do, but it’s milder For a twist, go with orange juice and zest—it gives a softer citrus pop Want it richer? Use half and half instead of milk Gluten free flour blends swap in just fine without messing up the taste
Pin it
Fun Serving Ideas
Spoon whipped cream or pile fresh berries on top Dust with powdered sugar if you like They really light up a table for coffee time Bring them as cute gifts in paper boxes for new neighbors or birthday treats
Fun Backstory
Impossible pies took over in the late 1900s because it was wild to pour a runny batter that magically turned into jammy custard with a soft base The lemon version always meant spring had started in our family My grandma used to say anything citrus was made for the sunshine
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why do people call these pies 'impossible'?
All the parts bake together and kind of separate on their own, so you get a buttery base and creamy top without lots of steps.
- → Can you swap in bottled lemon juice for fresh?
If you have to, go with bottled, but fresh lemons really bring out a stronger flavor.
- → What's the best way to keep leftovers?
Pop leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge. They'll stay good for about three days.
- → Are these pies freezer-friendly?
Yep! Let them cool, freeze in a single layer, and just defrost in the fridge before eating.
- → What toppings go well with these mini pies?
They're awesome with whipped cream, a handful of berries, or a sprinkle of powdered sugar on top.
- → Can I make them if I don’t do dairy?
You sure can! Use plant milk and vegan butter. The taste and feel might switch up a bit, but it works.