Pin it
This cozy Butternut Squash Apple Bake brings all those toasty fall flavors and aromas that make you want to grab a blanket. Juicy apples and soft squash get tossed with sweet brown sugar, cinnamon, and crunchy pecans. It makes for a super comforting side to your turkey or whatever you’re cooking on a chilly night. I come back to this mix every year, and it never fails to pull the family into the kitchen—probably chasing the smell of baked fruit in the oven.
I gave this a shot years ago at Thanksgiving because we had an overload of apples. Now my kids bug me to make it every year. The squishy sweetness and those cozy spices somehow win over even the usual squash haters at the table.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Dried cranberries: give a hit of tartness and keep the dish from getting too sweet. Look for plump ones—they just taste better.
- Pecans or walnuts: bring in crunch and earthy flavor. You'll want freshly shelled ones for the best texture.
- Raisins: give chewy sweetness. Try using golden ones for a sunny pop of color.
- Black pepper: adds just enough heat—crack it fresh if you can for a little zing.
- Salt: gives all the other flavors a little extra pop. A flaky or kosher salt works great.
- Butter: melts all over everything, making bites rich and smooth. Stick with unsalted to keep things balanced.
- Brown sugar: for that toasty caramel taste, light or dark. You could even use honey for something a little different.
- Vanilla extract: deepens the smell and rounds out the spice. Real vanilla makes the biggest difference.
- Cinnamon: dials up the warmth. Make sure yours hasn't been sitting around forever—fresh is best.
- Gala apples: or use Fuji, Honeycrisp, Macintosh—just go for firm, bright-colored apples for nice tartness and bite.
- Butternut squash: you’ll need about two cups, diced nice and even. Look for dull skin with no spots—that’s the good stuff.
Simple Step Guide
- Serve While Warm:
- Right before you start digging in, give it another gentle stir. Spoon it out while it's still nice and hot—the juices will get a little thicker as it sits, soaking into every bite.
- Add Nuts, Fruit, and Bake Again:
- Take the pan out, carefully peel back the cover, and toss in your pecans, raisins, and dried cranberries. Gently mix so the goodies are everywhere. Put the lid back on and return it to the oven for about fifteen more minutes. You're waiting for those squash cubes to be fork-tender and golden in spots.
- Bake the First Round:
- Pop a lid or some foil over your dish to keep in the warmth and steam. Bake at 400 degrees for about fifteen minutes—this gets the squash starting to soften and lets the flavors begin to blend.
- Scatter in Butter:
- Spread your squash and apples out in a baking dish to make a single layer. Tuck chunks of butter all over so it melts evenly as it bakes.
- Mix in Spices and Season:
- Sprinkle in black pepper and salt, then gently toss again to get a little seasoning on every bit.
- Start With Mixing:
- Grab a big bowl and add your squash, apples (peeled and chopped), brown sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla. Use your hands to mix so everything gets shiny and coated with all that good stuff.
Pin it
My favorite part? The way those chewy raisins and snappy pecans mix with soft squash in every spoonful. Honestly, sometimes we bake this just because it makes the house smell like family Sunday.
How to Store
Let it cool all the way before moving leftovers to a sealed container. Stash it in your fridge for up to three days. A quick zap in the microwave or reheat in the oven, and it’s good as new. Freezing? Sure—portion it into freezer bags after it's cooled and keep it up to a month. Just let it thaw in the fridge overnight before warming it up again.
Swap Options
No butternut squash on hand? Acorn squash is a perfect backup and has that same soft bite. Any sweet apple will do, and if you want, switch out brown sugar for honey or maple syrup for a twist on flavor. If nuts are an issue, just leave them out or toss in some pumpkin seeds instead for crunch.
Fresh Ways to Serve
Pin it
Spoon this one up next to roasted turkey, a pork roast, or a juicy ham. Try it as a warm mix-in for oatmeal or on top of yogurt for a fall breakfast. Or scoop it over pancakes with a drizzle of maple syrup and an extra shake of toasted nuts for a wild brunch treat.
History and Fun Facts
Squash and fruit bakes have been on holiday tables across the US and Europe for ages, bringing splashy color to winter meals and getting the most from the harvest. This version borrows from those old-school flavors, but strips away the fuss so you can get it on the table without breaking a sweat for big family gatherings.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use a different type of squash?
You sure can! Try swapping butternut for acorn squash. Just peel, scoop out the seeds, and chop it up the same way.
- → What apples work best for this dish?
Gala apples are fantastic, but you can use Honeycrisp or even Macintosh—just go for something sweet and sturdy.
- → How can I make this dish ahead?
Toss all your ingredients in the pan, cover it, and pop it in the fridge. Bake it right before you want to eat so it stays perfect.
- → Is there a way to make this without butter?
Totally—grab a plant-based butter, or you can drizzle in a little olive oil for a new twist.
- → How do I know when the squash is done?
If your fork slides in easily but the squash doesn't fall apart, you're good to go.