Pin it
Turn the popular McDonald's seasonal favorite into layered dessert cups you can make at home! These fun shamrock shake pudding cups mix chocolate and cool mint puddings in striking layers with fluffy whipped cream on top. The green and brown colors look amazing together and taste just as good. They're great for St. Patrick's Day parties or just to bring some Irish-inspired fun to your regular day.
I came up with these pudding cups when I needed something quick for a St. Patrick's Day get-together. Everyone couldn't stop staring at the pretty layers, and they were gone faster than anything else I served. My friend's kid (she's eight) told me they were "way better than the actual shamrock shake" because she "got chocolate in it too!" Now I can't get through March without someone asking me to make them.
Simple Ingredients You'll Need
- Chocolate pudding mix: Forms the dark, yummy base layer; grab the instant kind for quick assembly
- Mint pudding mix: Gives that classic minty taste that makes these cups stand out; check the variations if you can't find it
- Milk: Turns powder into pudding; full-fat makes it creamiest, but any milk works fine
- Whipped cream: Creates a fluffy topping that makes everything look and taste better
- Green food coloring: You can skip it, but it makes the mint layer pop with that true shamrock look
- Chocolate shavings: Adds a fancy touch and boosts the chocolate flavor
Don't skip on the toppings - they really make these cups special. I found that using a regular vegetable peeler on a good chocolate bar gives you these gorgeous curls that look way fancier than store-bought shavings. This tiny detail turns simple pudding cups into something that looks totally impressive.
Stir Up The Chocolate Part
Grab a bowl and whisk cold milk into your chocolate pudding mix until it's totally smooth. Let it sit for about 5 minutes until it thickens enough to spoon easily. You'll know it's ready when it holds its shape but still wiggles a little bit.
Whip Up The Green Layer
Take another bowl and mix the mint pudding with cold milk, whisking hard to get rid of any lumps. If you're using vanilla pudding with mint flavoring added, put in 3-4 drops of green food coloring to get that true shamrock green. Wait until it's nice and thick.
Stack Your Pudding Layers
Put chocolate pudding at the bottom of see-through cups or glasses. Using a pastry bag makes the neatest layers, but you can also spoon it in carefully so you don't mess up the sides of the glass. Add mint pudding next, then keep switching between chocolate and mint until your cups are almost full.
Crown With Whipped Cream
Add a big swirl of whipped cream on top of each cup. For a fancy look, try using a pastry bag with a star tip. The white cream looks amazing against the bright green mint layer.
Pin it
Dress Them Up Nicely
Scatter chocolate shavings, pieces of mint chocolate, or a bit of cocoa powder on top. For extra St. Patrick's Day spirit, add green sprinkles or a tiny mint leaf. These little extras make them look amazing and add nice texture.
Let Them Rest In The Fridge
Put your finished pudding cups in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes before serving. This waiting time lets all the flavors mix while making sure everything is perfectly cold and firm.
My daughter (she's nine) loves helping me make these pudding cups, especially when we add the green food coloring to get that perfect shamrock color. She totally believes that counting to ten while mixing makes the green more magical - and honestly, who am I to say it doesn't? Making these has turned into our special March tradition, bringing some fun to that time between winter and spring.
Ways To Enjoy Them
Finish off your St. Patrick's Day dinner of corned beef and cabbage with these fun dessert cups. They're great for classroom parties or office celebrations too, adding holiday cheer without needing any fancy decorating skills. For a cozy family movie night in March, pair them with hot cocoa. Since they come in individual servings, they're perfect for parties where guests can easily grab their own complete dessert.
Tasty Twists To Try
Change these cups to suit different tastes and diets. For folks who don't do dairy, swap in almond or coconut milk and non-dairy whipped topping. Can't find mint pudding? Just use vanilla pudding mix with 1/4 teaspoon mint extract and some green coloring. Want a grown-up version? Add a spoonful of Irish cream liqueur to each cup. For a cookies-and-cream spin, put some crushed chocolate cookies between the pudding layers. Love grasshopper pie? Start with a chocolate cookie bottom in each cup.
Prep Now, Enjoy Later
You can make these cups a whole day ahead and keep them covered in your fridge. For the freshest look, wait to add the whipped cream and toppings until an hour or two before serving. If you need to make them even earlier, just prepare both puddings separately, keep them covered in the fridge, and put everything together on the day you'll serve them. This makes party planning so much easier!
Pin it
I've noticed these simple pudding cups bring way more happiness than the small amount of work they take. There's something really special about those bright green and brown layers that makes people smile before they even take a bite. Maybe it's the fun colors, the cute presentation, or just how good chocolate and mint taste together - whatever it is, these shamrock shake pudding cups have become a tradition we all look forward to in our house. They're our little way of welcoming spring with some sweetness and fun.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep these ahead of time?
- For sure! Just put them together up to a day early, but hold off on adding whipped cream and decorations until right before serving so they look fresh.
- → What if I can't find mint pudding?
- Don't worry—mix vanilla pudding with 1/2 teaspoon of mint extract and a little green dye. Start with the smallest amount of extract and taste as you go.
- → Is there a way to make these dairy-free?
- Sure! Opt for almond, coconut, or soy milk to make the pudding. Use a dairy-free whipped topping to finish them off. Just note the pudding may feel a little softer.
- → What other toppings work besides chocolate shavings?
- Think mini mints, crushed cookies, colorful sprinkles, even edible gold or silver accents. A small mint leaf adds a fancy touch, too!
- → How can I make this work for parties?
- Use clear plastic cups to let folks enjoy the pretty layers. Or turn it into a dessert bar—prepare the layers, and put toppings out so guests can get creative.