Pin it
You’ll taste Louisiana’s vibe in every forkful of this Cajun-inspired seafood pot pie. Juicy seafood hangs out with soft veggies, all coated in a rich, creamy Cajun sauce, then tucked inside a crispy, golden shell. Make it when you want to wow your friends or bring everyone together around a cozy dish with a nice little spicy twist.
The first time I cooked this was for someone’s birthday get-together. Even the folks who are usually super picky went back for thirds. Now I end up bringing it out at almost every party.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Seafood mix like crab or shrimp: sweet, salty flavors and plenty of bite—grab the best you can find for flavor
- Onions (diced): throws in some sweetness and heart—pick heavy, solid ones
- Celery: fresh snap and crunch—go for crisp, bright stalks
- Bell peppers: classic Cajun color and a touch of earthiness—any color is good, but green or red nails the vibe
- Fresh garlic (minced): makes everything pop with aroma—use real garlic for the biggest punch
- Butter: all about fuller flavor, helps make the roux right—unsalted is best for control
- Flour (all-purpose): thickens things up—unbleached tastes a little heartier
- Seafood broth: piles on savory notes—homemade or a good jarred kind is great
- Full-fat cream: pure silkiness—heavy cream gives it that dreamy feel
- Your favorite Cajun seasoning: everything comes together here—use a blend with paprika, thyme, plus a hint of spicy cayenne
- Pie crust: for super crisp finish—cold dough makes it so much better
Simple How-To
- Heat up your oven and roll out the crust:
- Get your oven hot to 375, then lay out the pie crust. Let it chill while you cook the filling so it stays extra flaky.
- Cook the filling base:
- Start with butter in a skillet on medium. Toss in onions, celery, and bell peppers. Stir around till they’re super soft, then drop in the garlic. A couple more minutes for everything to smell amazing.
- Whip up a thick, creamy sauce:
- Stir in the flour—don’t stop stirring till it’s smooth and turning a bit tan. Slowly pour in seafood stock and cream, whisking till it’s nice and silky and just barely bubbling.
- Add flavor and seafood:
- Sprinkle in Cajun spices, then slide in your seafood. Just gently cook till the seafood curls and gets glossy—no overcooking allowed, you want juicy bites.
- Put it all together:
- Place a pie crust in your pan, pour in all that creamy seafood filling, and spread it flat. Top with the other crust, pinch the edges to seal and poke a couple of steam holes with a knife.
- Final bake and cool down:
- Stick it in the oven’s middle rack for half an hour or so. Pull it out when the top is deeply golden and bubbles are peeking at the edges. Cool a bit before slicing, so it all holds together.
Pin it
The Cajun spice blend ties every bite together—earthy, just enough heat, and really rich flavor. My dad used to show me how to mix spices from scratch, so throwing in that first spoonful always makes the kitchen feel like home again.
Best Storage Ideas
Keep leftovers chilled and covered for up to three days. Reheat in the oven on medium heat to bring back that fresh, crisp crust and the warm gooey filling—no soggy bottom here.
Swaps That Work
No crab or crawfish? Shrimp does the trick. Half and half instead of heavy cream gives a lighter touch. For gluten free, go with gluten free flour and crust—they work just fine.
Fun Ways to Serve
Try it with a simple tossed salad and lemon wedges for a fresh taste. If you’re into more heat, add a splash of hot sauce. Hearty eaters love it with cornbread or warm garlic bread on the side too.
Pin it
Local Flavor
This dish takes its vibe from south Louisiana's Cajun kitchens—seafood everywhere and the holy trinity of onion, celery, pepper in just about everything. Pot pies made use of whatever the day’s catch was, pulling together big flavors in one warm, shareable meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which seafood goes well in this pie?
Shrimp, crawfish, and crab are the classics, but white fish or scallops can make it extra tasty too.
- → How can I stop the bottom from getting mushy?
Give the crust a head start by baking it alone first, and keep the filling from being too wet before you pour it in.
- → Can I prep this ahead?
Totally! Put it all together, stash it in the fridge, then pop it in the oven right before you eat so the crust stays crunchy.
- → Is there a homemade swap for Cajun blend?
You can make your own with paprika, thyme, garlic powder, oregano, and a touch of cayenne.
- → Can frozen seafood be used here?
Yeah, frozen works—just thaw and drain so your pie doesn’t end up watery inside.