Pin it
Turkish Meatballs with Creamy Yogurt are real showstoppers with barely any hassle. You get a hit of cozy spices when you bite into the juicy meatballs wrapped in a tangy, creamy blanket. Toss in some tart pickled onions and spicy Aleppo oil—that zip of flavor brightens up every bite. Anytime I serve this at family get-togethers, even folks who swear they’re not meatball fans suddenly want seconds.
I started throwing this together on busy nights when I needed something that was both simple and exciting. Now, it’s the most-requested dish anytime someone’s coming over for dinner.
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Cornstarch: Thickens up the sauce so it turns glossy and smooth
- Pickled red onions Optional: A pop of brightness and crunch—totally ups the look too
- Kosher salt and black pepper: Use a heavy hand to really season everything; fresh ground pepper smells so good
- Aleppo pepper flakes: Gives the oil a warm reddish color and a gentle kick
- Extra virgin olive oil: Grab a bold kind if you can for the finishing drizzle
- Chicken or veggie broth: Adds a yummy richness; pick one that's low in salt if possible
- Greek yogurt: Use full fat for creaminess or whole milk if you can’t find it
- Egg (for the sauce): Makes your sauce rich but still feels silky
- Water: Mixes with cornstarch to keep the sauce lump-free
- Bread: Makes meatballs soft and moist—use a chunky slice torn up
- Lean beef or a beef-lamb mix: Either is tasty but mixing in lamb really kicks up the flavor; a bit of fat makes things juicy
- Large onion diced: Keeps things moist and adds a sweet hint
- Garlic cloves minced: For a punch of flavor; fresh is best
- Flat leaf parsley finely chopped: Adds freshness and a wash of color
- Egg: Holds everything together; go for a large one
- Cumin and coriander: Give a deep, slightly earthy vibe; freshly ground if possible
- Urfa Biber: Smoky, mild chili—worth hunting down, but swap in red flakes if you can't
- Aleppo pepper: Soft heat with some fruity notes; brightens up the dish
Easy StepbyStep Directions
- Put it all together:
- Lay your cooked meatballs in a big, shallow bowl. Pour on the cozy yogurt sauce. Add pickled onions if you feel fancy. Spoon over your spicy oil and get it to the table while it’s still nice and warm.
- Make the Aleppo oil:
- Warm a splash of olive oil in a small pan and stir in Aleppo pepper flakes. Swirl around just until it turns a deep amber and starts to smell wildly good—don’t let it burn!
- Finish up the yogurt sauce:
- Bring broth to a simmer. Keep the heat super low. Pour in the yogurt mix bit by bit, whisking like crazy so nothing curdles. Keep stirring until it thickens a little—then take it off the burner and pop a lid on. Serve warm (not piping hot).
- Mix the yogurt base:
- While your meatballs are cooking, whisk together cornstarch and water in a bowl until smooth. Add the egg, then yogurt, salt, and pepper—beat until blended and creamy.
- Bake them off:
- Bake on the middle rack until golden outside and cooked through in the center. This should take about fifteen to twenty minutes. If you crave a crunchier crust, turn on the broiler for the last couple of minutes.
- Shape your meatballs:
- Line your sheet pan with parchment. Scoop out about two tablespoons at a time and roll into balls—should get you eighteen to twenty. Arrange with a bit of space so they brown up nicely, not steam.
- Mix up the meat:
- In a big bowl, toss together the soaked bread bits, ground meat, onion, garlic, parsley, egg, cumin, coriander, Urfa Biber, Aleppo pepper, and season it up with salt and pepper. Use your hands and mix gently—don’t mash it. This keeps meatballs soft.
- Prep your bread:
- Toast the bread so it smells nutty, then soak in water until mushy but don’t let it get soggy. Squeeze out the liquid, tear the bread into tiny chunks. That’ll help make meatballs extra light.
- Get your oven ready:
- Slide the oven rack to the middle and turn the heat to four twenty five Fahrenheit—it browns the meatballs all over and cooks them evenly.
Pin it
The part I crave most is that spicy Aleppo oil. The aroma hits you and makes the whole kitchen feel cozier. First time I tried these was at a Turkish wedding—every bite felt perfectly balanced with all the flavors mixed together.
Storage Hacks
Let everything cool off before putting away. Store meatballs and yogurt sauce in separate containers with tight lids in your fridge. They’re good for up to three days. When reheating, keep the dish covered and heat gently so the yogurt sauce stays smooth. Got extra meatballs? Stuff 'em into pita or toss on top of salad greens.
Ingredient Swaps
No Urfa Biber or Aleppo pepper? Swap for mild red chili flakes or even paprika. If lamb isn’t available, all beef works, or use ground turkey to lighten things up. Full-fat yogurt is best, but whole milk yogurt can step in if you need it.
How To Serve
Dole out these meatballs as your main, paired with fluffy rice or toasty flatbreads. The yogurt sauce is awesome as a veggie dip too. For a big dinner spread, toss in a crisp salad or simple greens. Sprinkle on pickled onions and extra fresh dill at the end for a classic touch.
Pin it
Food Roots and Traditions
Kofte (that’s Turkish for meatball) shows up everywhere across Turkey, with every place giving it a personal spin—different spices, different cooking tricks. The creamy, gently thickened yogurt sauce is a classic in Anatolia and lets this version stand out from the rest.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What gives Turkish meatballs that bold flavor?
Old-school Turkish spices like coriander, Aleppo pepper, cumin, and Urfa Biber get mixed in, building up deep taste and mild heat.
- → How do you make the yogurt sauce?
Mix Greek yogurt with a whisked egg, some broth, and a spoonful of cornstarch, then heat it slow for a thick, creamy sauce with a little tang.
- → Do I have to stick to just beef or lamb?
Not at all! Try both meats for more flavor. If your beef's lean, a splash of olive oil keeps everything juicy.
- → What’s the magic of Aleppo pepper here?
It’s got gentle heat and a fruity twist, especially after you sizzle it in olive oil and pour all that on at the end.
- → Why toss in pickled onions?
They snap and zing, cutting through creamy yogurt and rich meatballs so nothing gets too heavy.
- → Can you make this ahead of time?
Bake your meatballs early and keep them ready. Just fix the sauce right before eating so it stays creamy and smooth.