Pin it
Making Thumbprint Cookies always takes me back to baking days with grandma. Feeling that buttery mix squeeze through my fingers and creating those little jam pockets was pure joy. It's crazy how a few basic ingredients turn into something so tasty. The warm, homey smell that fills my kitchen when they're baking just screams holiday season.
What Makes These So Special
I'm totally hooked on how straightforward these cookies are. You get that melt-away buttery base with a bright jam surprise in the middle. Beginners and kitchen experts alike can nail these pretty treats. They're what I reach for when I want something impressive but don't have all day to spend baking.
Your Ingredient List
- Butter: One cup at room temperature for that can't-beat melt-in-your-mouth texture.
- Brown Sugar: A third cup brings that subtle caramel flavor.
- Vanilla Extract: Just one teaspoon for that cozy background note.
- All-Purpose Flour: About two cups, sifted for extra softness.
- Salt: A quarter teaspoon to balance everything out.
- Jam: Half cup of whatever you like, raspberry's my personal favorite.
Step-by-Step Guide
- Mix your wet ingredients:
- Beat the butter and brown sugar until super fluffy then add your vanilla.
- Add your dry stuff:
- Slowly mix in the flour and salt until everything comes together in a soft dough.
- Shape your cookies:
- Form small balls and push your thumb in each to create jam wells. Pop them in the fridge to firm up.
- Add jam and bake:
- Drop your favorite jam in each indent and bake until the edges turn slightly golden.
Insider Cookie Tips
Switching up jams can be so fun, apricot makes for an amazing surprise and orange marmalade adds such a zingy twist. Store them in something airtight or freeze them for later. I sometimes freeze the shaped unbaked dough so I can have warm cookies ready when friends stop by unexpectedly.
Double Batch Warning
I've learned my lesson about making just one batch of these cookies. They disappear way too fast and I'm always left wanting more. That combo of buttery goodness and sweet jam center is totally addictive. Now I automatically double the recipe so I have plenty for sharing and enough to enjoy throughout the holiday season.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why make the thumbprint after pre-baking?
Doing this halfway through lets the dough firm up enough to press without all the cracks you'd get otherwise.
- → Can I swap in other jams?
Totally—raspberry is great, but strawberry, apricot, or any other jam you love will work just as well.
- → How do I stop the jam from overflowing?
Use only a tiny scoop of jam—around 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon—for each cookie. It'll bake neatly without spilling over.
- → What's with just using the yolk?
Skipping the whites and keeping the yellows makes the cookies buttery and soft since yolks have all the richness.
- → Can I freeze them for later?
Yep! Layer the cookies with wax paper in a sealed container. They'll stay fresh in the freezer for up to 3 months.
Conclusion
These jam-filled, buttery cookies are a delicious classic for the holidays. Made with just a few staples, they're an easy crowd-pleaser everyone will enjoy.