Pin it
This velvety sweet onion blend jazzes up cold sandwiches grilled chicken salads or oven veggies with deep tang and smooth sweetness. Taking cues from your favorite sandwich shop but with a personal touch this homemade staple gives any meal a sweet kick and creamy boost you’ll crave all week.
The first time I whipped this up was burger night and now every family gathering means someone’s walking off with a jar—they just can’t get enough!
Luscious Ingredients
- Black pepper: brings a mild bite and rounds things out—let cracked pepper wake up the flavors
- Paprika: adds a warm gentle sweetness and color—seek out a fresh bright red powder
- Celery seed: tosses in a hint of herbal tang that brightens up everything
- Garlic powder: sharpens up the sauce with a pop but never overpowers
- Salt: smooths out the sweet and ties it all together
- Onion powder: amps up onion flavor—go for a vibrant fresh one
- Sesame oil: layers in a soft nutty note—try toasted for richer depth
- Poppy seeds: sprinkle in a pop of crunch and soft nutty flavor—toast ‘em if you’re feeling fancy
- Mustard powder: gives a punch of flavor and wraps everything up nicely
- Dijon mustard: adds a bit of zip and helps make the sauce creamy—pick a smooth type you like
- Cornstarch: thickens everything up—keep it lump-free for that dreamy consistency
- Freshly grated onion: offers mellow sweetness—choose Vidalia or yellow for best results
- Red wine vinegar: adds bold depth—good quality stuff really shines
- White vinegar: brightens the mix—creates that familiar tangy hit
- Water: thins it just enough so you can drizzle it anywhere
- Sugar: forms the sweet base—cane sugar brings out the onions best
Easy Directions
- Cool and Store:
- Take the pan off the heat. Chill the sauce till it’s just warm or at room temperature then pour it into a jar or another container with a tight lid. It thickens more as it cools. Pop it in the fridge and try to use it up within a week.
- Simmer:
- Turn down the heat and let the sauce gently bubble for five minutes more. Keep whisking now and then so it stays creamy and doesn’t get clumpy.
- Boil and Thicken:
- Stay close as it bubbles to a boil. Let it cook for five minutes whisking non-stop. Don’t let anything stick or burn—keep scraping the bottom if you have to!
- Whisk and Heat:
- Put the pan on medium-high and start whisking quickly. This melts the sugar and keeps the cornstarch perfectly smooth.
- Combine All Ingredients:
- Dump sugar, water, both vinegars, onion, cornstarch, both mustards, poppy seeds, sesame oil, onion powder, salt, garlic powder, celery seed, paprika, and black pepper into a medium pot. Stir till you’ve got no weird lumps.
Pin it
Poppy seeds make every bite fun for me. My kiddo tasted it with chicken strips and declared it ‘magic sauce.’ So now it has a new home nickname.
How to Keep It Fresh
Let the sauce cool then stash it tightly closed in the fridge for up to a week. Always use a clean spoon and a tight jar. If it looks thicker after chilling just stir it around before using again—it’s normal!
Swaps and Shortcuts
Need less sugar? Go with honey or agave instead. Try using a quarter cup less sugar for a bigger tang. You can trade out Dijon for yellow if you want it milder or leave out poppy seeds if those aren’t your thing.
Ways to Serve
Splash plenty over leafy salads, tuck inside a roast beef sandwich, spoon onto grilled chicken, or let it soak into meat before it cooks. Dip veggies or potato wedges right in too—it’s good any way!
Pin it
How This Sauce Started
Sauces like this one made their name on sub sandwiches with that punchy sweet taste. Making it at home means you get to play with the ingredients and adjust the flavor as you like.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What makes this onion sauce stand out?
You'll taste a lively zip from grated onion, Dijon, and poppy seeds, with a vinegary background and a little aroma from spices.
- → Is there a way to tone down the sweetness?
Just cut back the sugar or use your favorite swap to keep the sauce a bit less sweet but still delicious.
- → Can I use this as a marinade if I want?
Absolutely, it's great for soaking chicken, veggies, or tofu and brings tons of flavor and a bit of moisture, too.
- → How should I keep leftovers, and for how long?
Pop it in a sealed jar and stash it in the fridge. It'll be good for about a week and still taste fresh.
- → Does this sauce get thicker as it sits?
Once it cools a bit, the cornstarch works its magic and gives you a glossy, drizzle-ready sauce.
- → What's the best way to add extra heat?
If you want a little kick, sprinkle in extra pepper or toss in a few chili flakes. Try it and see how you like it!